Nassau County, Long Island, is a true paradise for bakery lovers, with spots offering everything from classic Italian pastries to creative, gourmet desserts. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh bread, a custom birthday cake, or just want to grab a box of cookies for a sweet pick-me-up, there’s a bakery here for every craving. Get ready to indulge because we’ve rounded up the best bakeries in Nassau County you need to check out!
1. St. Rocco’s Bakery – Glen Cove
A fixture in Glen Cove, St. Rocco’s Bakery is known for its traditional Italian pastries and fresh-baked bread. Cannolis filled on the spot, classic Italian cookies, and their famous prosciutto bread make this bakery a local treasure. Whether you’re after a sweet treat or a loaf of bread, St. Rocco’s offers a nostalgic, authentic experience.
Location: 4 Saint Rocco Pl, Glen Cove, NY 11542
Best for: Cannoli, biscotti, and prosciutto bread
2. Cardinali Bakery – Carle Place
We can’t have a list of the best bakeries in Nassau County without mentioning Cardinali Bakery, a long-standing institution in Carle Place known for its diverse menu of baked goods ranging from Italian pastries to intricate specialty cakes. Their cannoli, tiramisu, and rainbow cookies are highly recommended, and their selection of fresh bread is unbeatable. Cardinali’s also specializes in custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, and special events, making it a must-visit for anyone planning a celebration.
Location: 465 Westbury Ave, Carle Place, NY 11514
Best for: Custom cakes, tiramisu, and Italian cookies
3. Front Street Bakery – Rockville Centre
For crumb cake lovers, Front Street Bakery is one of the best bakeries in Nassau County. This Rockville Centre institution offers some of the best crumb cakes in the area, chocolate chip cookies and custom cakes. Front Street is also known for its warm, inviting atmosphere, making it a neighborhood favorite for years.
Location: 51 Front St, Rockville Centre, NY 11570
Best for: Crumb cakes and their famous dot cookies
4. Buttercooky Bakery – Floral Park, Manhasset
Buttercooky Bakery delivers a combination of French-inspired pastries and classic American favorites. Their beautifully decorated cakes, Black Forest cake, and Linzer tarts are standout items. For those with a sweet tooth, their butter cookies and cupcakes are perfect for any occasion.
Location: 217 Jericho Turnpike, Floral Park, NY 11001
Best for: Linzer tarts and custom cakes
5. The French Workshop – Garden City
For a sophisticated take on baked goods, The French Workshop in Garden City is an excellent choice. Known for its croissants, éclairs, and artisan breads, this bakery blends classic French baking techniques with modern flavors. It’s a great spot to pick up a beautifully crafted dessert or sit down for a pastry and coffee. Out of all the shops listed in our best bakeries in Nassau County list, The French Workshop is a must for traditionalists.
Location: 191 7th St, Garden City, NY 11530
Best for: Croissants, éclairs, and gourmet cakes
6. Dortoni Bakery – Levittown
Dortoni Bakery in Levittown is known for its classic Italian desserts, such as cannoli and Napoleon cakes. Their cheesecakes and cookies are some of the best around, and their artisanal bread makes it a go-to for both sweet and savory options.
Location: 3264 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown, NY 11756
Best for: Napoleon cake and cheesecake
7. Whistle Stop Bake Shop – Oceanside
Whistle Stop Bake Shop is a beloved local gem in Oceanside, NY. Known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere and delicious, freshly baked goods, this bakery has become a go-to spot for sweet treats, special occasion desserts and their cheesecake! Whether you’re craving a classic cookie, a beautifully designed cake, or a buttery pastry, Whistle Stop Bakery delivers exceptional quality and attention to detail.
Their custom cakes are particularly popular, offering a wide variety of flavors and designs that make any event extra special.
Location: 3424 Lawson Blvd, Oceanside, NY 11572
Best for: Cheesecake
If you’re looking for the best bakeries in Nassau County, refer to our list and see why we called out these shops in particular. From traditional Italian pastries to modern French-inspired desserts, Nassau County’s bakeries have something for everyone.
