There’s something timelessly charming about afternoon tea. Maybe it’s the clink of fine china, the delicate tiers of pastries, or the feeling that just for a little while you’ve stepped into a more elegant pace of life. Whatever the reason, traditional tea is having a moment, and Nassau County is serving it up beautifully.
Whether you’re after elegant sophistication over tea service in a historic hotel, a charming, cozy spot with classic comfort fare and a broad selection of teas, or a playful, pastel-filled café perfect for dessert and drinks, Nassau County serves up a delightful variety of tea-inspired experiences. From refined afternoon tea pairings that feel like a special occasion to relaxed cafés that make any mid-day pause sweet and stylish, here are three must-visit spots in Nassau County, Long Island.
Swing the Teapot — Floral Park
Address: 6 Verbena Avenue, Floral Park, NY 11001
Part cozy Irish café, part whimsical tea house, Swing the Teapot is a Floral Park favorite that feels like a delightful discovery every time you visit. Tucked just off the main avenue, this charming spot is known for its warm hospitality, eclectic décor, and relaxed, linger-a-little-longer vibe.
Inside, the atmosphere feels straight out of a storybook, with mismatched chairs, antique teapots, and vintage details spread across several intimate dining rooms. The result is equal parts rustic and playful, perfect for leisurely meals, casual gatherings, or a quiet afternoon with a pot of tea.
Swing the Teapot serves breakfast, brunch, lunch, and casual dinner, with a menu that blends Irish comfort classics and café favorites. Hearty dishes like shepherd’s pie and a traditional Irish breakfast sit alongside lighter options, all thoughtfully paired with an extensive tea selection served in individual teapots, from classic black teas to herbal and flavored blends.
Locally owned and deeply rooted in the community, Swing the Teapot also hosts live music and themed tea events, adding to its welcoming, neighborhood charm.
Don’t miss: Their tea service paired with live music or a themed afternoon, it’s one of the most memorable tea experiences in Nassau County.
Garden City Hotel — Garden City
Address: 45 Seventh Street, Garden City, NY 11530
For those looking to experience afternoon tea with a side of old-world glamour, the Garden City Hotel delivers in a big way.
Set inside one of Long Island’s most iconic historic hotels, afternoon tea here feels elegant, refined, and indulgent. The setting alone, grand architecture, plush interiors, and polished service sets the tone for a luxurious escape.
Their traditional afternoon tea service includes premium teas, classic finger sandwiches, freshly baked scones, and beautifully crafted pastries, all presented with the level of sophistication you’d expect from a landmark hotel. It’s the kind of place where dressing up feels right and lingering over your teacup is practically encouraged.
Perfect for special occasions or for when you simply want to treat yourself, the Garden City Hotel’s tea service is a reminder that sometimes, luxury is slowing down and savoring the moment.
Don’t miss: Pairing tea with a post-tea stroll through Garden City’s charming downtown.
The Pink Café & Bakery — Rockville Centre
Address: 24 N Park Avenue, Rockville Centre, NY 11570
A bright and charming bakery-café with exceptionally Instagram-worthy desserts and an aesthetic that’s already drawing attention from locals and visitors alike. The Pink Café & Bakery isn’t a classic British afternoon-tea house, but it does deliver a playful, pastel-filled vibe perfect for sweet treats, specialty drinks, and cozy catch-ups.
This spot has been praised for its freshly baked pastries, cupcakes, brownies, and other eye-catching confections, all ideal to enjoy with coffee or tea. The café is known for its friendly service and lively atmosphere, with plenty of visitors stopping in to capture photos of the pink-themed interiors and ever-changing dessert displays.
Whether you’re stopping by for a coffee and cupcake break, a tea with friends, or just to indulge your sweet tooth, The Pink Café offers a lighthearted, delightful experience that puts a fun twist on your typical bakery visit.
Pro tip: check their Instagram for daily updates on seasonal pastries and featured sweets before you go.
A Tea Lover’s To-Do List in Nassau County
One of the best things about traditional tea in Nassau County is how distinct each experience feels. From cozy and whimsical to polished and grand, there’s truly a tea table for every mood and occasion.
Pro tips for your tea adventure:
- Make reservations when possible; afternoon tea is popular, especially on weekends.
- Don’t rush it! Tea is meant to be savored.
- Bring a friend (or three). Tea is always better shared.
So go ahead, raise your pinky, pour another cup, and explore the charming world of traditional teas and fun Cafés right here in Nassau County. You might just find your new favorite afternoon tea ritual in Nassau County.
More to explore, one teacup at a time.
