Most Nostalgic Restaurants in Nassau County, New York

Nostalgia has a unique way of bridging the past and present, especially when it comes to food. There are a handful of incredible restaurants in Nassau County that can take both residents and visitors alike on a trip back in time. From classic diners to family-owned sweet shops, Nassau County has a variety of eateries that have stood the test of time. Whether you’re a long-time resident reminiscing about childhood favorites or a visitor who wants to experience the authentic tastes of Long Island, these restaurants are sure to make you feel right at home. Check out Nassau County’s best and most nostalgic eateries.

First opened in 1927, Hildebrandt’s is a Nassau County staple. Located in Williston Park, this 1920s-themed ice cream parlor and restaurant has become a beloved landmark, thanks to its kitschy vintage charm. Equally as great as the vibe is the menu. Renowned for their hand-crafted ice cream, those with a sweet tooth can enjoy a variety of flavors including chocolate, mint chip, strawberry, and so much more, all of which are made on-site. Beyond ice cream, Hildebrandt’s has food options like burgers, sandwiches, and salads.

Established in 1946, Thomas’s Ham & Eggery Diner in Carle Place is one of the best restaurants in Nassau county and has some of the best food around. With a focus on breakfasts and equally satisfying lunches, there’s something here for everyone. Breakfast is served all day, offering favorites like big omelets, hearty scrambles, and delicious breakfast wraps. For lunch, patrons can have specialty burgers, sandwiches, and salads, as well as comfort food favorites like pot roast, meatloaf, and pork chops. Don’t miss some of Thomas’s Specialties, which rotate every week. Expect to see dishes like mouthwatering egg sandwich melts and smoked tuna tartine. (Follow their Instagram page to stay up to date with the Specialties.)

Formerly known as The Laurel Luncheonette, Laurel Diner in Long Beach has been serving customers for over 90 years. (It has been around since 1932!) This family-owned restaurant is a local favorite thanks to its tasty selection of traditional American fare, retro decor, and friendly service. Guests can nosh on burgers, sandwiches, wings, steak, and so much more since the menu is absolutely massive. One of the highlights of the Laurel Diner is the Mug Full O’ Pie dessert, which consists of a beer mug full of hot fruit pie with a scoop of ice cream, caramel, whipped cream, and granola on top. Here, people feel right at home thanks to the welcoming atmosphere and fun vibe.

Krisch’s is a beloved institution in Nassau County. Since opening its doors in 1920, this Massapequa spot has been a favorite, known for its good food and old-fashioned charm. It’s famous for its classic diner fare, including breakfast, juicy burgers, and comforting sandwiches, all served in a cool, throwback atmosphere. However, their homemade ice cream is the star of the show, with a variety of flavors to choose from. Plus, they come out with new flavors every now and again, so guests can always look forward to trying something new. Oh, and the sundaes are also a must-try, generously topped with hot fudge, whipped cream, and (of course) cherries. Be sure to get a booth as we’re sure you’re going to want to stay awhile.

Located in the heart of Glen Cove, Sid’s All American is a retro-inspired restaurant with one of the best menus around. Here, foodies can find a mouthwatering selection of traditional American favorites, each made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their burgers and hot dogs are the main highlights and can be topped with all kinds of fixings. Sid’s is also famous for its frosted flake chicken tenders and crispy fries, so don’t miss out. This place does get pretty busy on the weekends, so go early if you want to get a table by the windows.

Plain and simple, Mineola Diner is cute, quaint, and ultra nostalgic. This delicious Mineola spot has got it all, including an extensive menu that caters to a wide range of tastes. Guests will find everything from breakfast favorites and lunch staples to ‘Funtastic Finger Foods,’ triple-decker sandwiches, and even some Greek options. We suggest trying the Chicken Supreme Sandwich, which is made with a crispy chicken cutlet smothered with melted mozzarella, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, and your choice of dressing on a hero or wrap. Plus, the brunch menu is pretty incredible, so if you’re looking for a brunch spot, this should be at the top of your list.

Marvel Frozen Dairy has been serving up delicious sweet treats since 1951. Located in Lido Beach and Long Beach, this family-owned ice cream stand is best known for its creamy soft serve and friendly service. The menu includes fan-favorite flavors such as vanilla, pistachio, coffee, dulce de leche, and chocolate, as well as the option to do a swirl, or mix of two flavors. Plus, they have non-fat Greek yogurt and vegan options. What’s more, they have a ton of toppings (think rainbow sprinkles, chocolate chips, toasted coconut, and more) as well as custom cakes, ice cream sandwiches, and slushies. It’s the perfect place to stop by after a long day in the sun – the ice cream is sure to cool you down in minutes.

Henry’s Confectionery is a family-owned diner that has been around since 1929. Located in Glen Cove, it has a great old-school vibe that makes people feel instantly comfortable. Plus, the menu is hard to beat. For breakfast (which is served all day), diners can enjoy fluffy pancakes, crispy bacon, and delicious egg dishes, while lunch options include deli sandwiches, savory soups, and fresh salads. However, it’s the homemade ice cream and desserts that truly steal the show. They also have homemade muffins that are sure to make anyone’s mouth water. However, one of the best things about this spot is that it’s a true local hangout. Don’t be surprised if you see the same people there every time you go.