Where to Find the Best Thanksgiving Pies and Desserts in Nassau County
Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and if you’re looking to bring a show-stopping pie or a few irresistible desserts to the table, Nassau County has some of the best bakeries and farms around. From traditional apple and pumpkin to indulgent pecan and tart creations, these local spots offer handcrafted pies and desserts bursting with flavor, all made right here in Nassau County, Long Island.
- Youngs Farm – Glen Head
Address: 91 Hegemans Lane, Old Brookville, NY 11545
Since 1893, Youngs Farm has been an Old Brookville staple, serving up freshly baked goods and farm-fresh produce from its charming country market. Their bakery menu changes daily and seasonally, featuring pies that highlight what’s freshest from the orchard.
For Thanksgiving, their classic apple pie made with locally grown apples is always a standout. You’ll also find dark cherry, coconut, and pumpkin pies that look as good as they taste. Each pie comes with a perfectly flaky crust and balanced sweetness that makes it a centerpiece for your holiday dessert table.
- Jericho Cider Mill – Jericho
Address: 213 Route 106, Jericho, NY 11753
This historic cider mill has been pressing apples and baking pies for over 200 years, and it’s as authentic as it gets. For Thanksgiving, their apple crumb pie and apple-raspberry pie are fan favorites each bursting with warm spice, tender fruit, and a golden-brown crumble topping.
Jericho Cider Mill’s pumpkin pie is also a seasonal hit, pairing perfectly with their fresh-pressed apple cider. The rustic charm and aroma of baking apples make this stop feel like the essence of fall on Long Island.
- Buttercooky Bakery & Café – Floral Park and Manhasset
Address: 217 Jericho Turnpike, Floral Park, NY 1100; 140 Plandome Road, Manhasset, NY 11030
A Long Island institution since 1962, Buttercooky Bakery is known for its European-style desserts and full holiday pie lineup. Their pumpkin pie and apple crumb pie are Thanksgiving staples, but you can also find blueberry crumb, cherry lattice, and pecan varieties perfect for hosts who want a dessert assortment.
Buttercooky’s pies are as beautiful as they are delicious, often finished with a decorative lattice or spiced topping. Multiple locations mean easy pickup before the holiday rush, and they accept advance orders online and by phone.
- Sapienza Bake Shop – Elmont
Address: 1376 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003
A third-generation, family-owned bakery, Sapienza Bake Shop has been serving Long Island since the 1960s with authentic Italian pastries, cookies, and custom desserts. Famous for their rainbow cookies, cannoli, sfogliatelle, and lobster tails, Sapienza blends tradition with creativity in every bite. For Thanksgiving, their pie lineup features the classics favorites like apple crumb and blueberry.
Each dessert is made fresh with high-quality ingredients and the kind of craftsmanship that’s made Sapienza a local favorite for decades.
- Dortoni Bakery Co.– Levittown
Address: 3264 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown, NY 11756
Dortoni Bakery blends old-world craftsmanship with modern holiday indulgence. Established in 1976, it’s a go-to for beautifully baked pies and pastries. For Thanksgiving, their coconut custard and mince pies are must-trys, both rich, buttery, and filled with flavor. They also offer pumpkin and classic berry pies, making it easy to satisfy everyone’s preferences.
Beyond pies, Dortoni shines with rich cannoli, éclairs, tiramisu and other hand-made pastries that make any holiday table feel complete. With its wide variety and attention to detail, Dortoni is a Nassau County classic for any family gathering.
- Polka Dot Pound Cake Café – Rockville Centre
Address: 217 N. Long Beach Road, Rockville Centre, NY 11570
Polka Dot Pound Cake Café is known for charming treats and inventive holiday desserts. While their signature item is the pound cake, their Thanksgiving pie lineup shouldn’t be overlooked. Try the cranberry-apple pie for a tart twist on tradition, or their apple cheese tart for guests seeking something decadent and different.
The café also serves coffee and seasonal beverages, a perfect pairing for pie pickup day.
From farm-fresh spots to family-run bakeries, Nassau County is home to some of Long Island’s most flavorful pies and desserts, the kind that make Thanksgiving dinner unforgettable.
