Bagel Bliss: Discover The Best Bagels in Nassau County

If there’s one thing Nassau County, Long Island does exceptionally well, it’s bagels. With their perfect balance of chewy interiors and crispy exteriors, Long Island bagels are famous for good reason. And what better time to celebrate these carb-loaded delights than on National Bagel Day, January 15, 2025? Whether you’re craving a classic plain bagel or something with more pizzazz, Nassau County has no shortage of fantastic options. To mark this special day, we’re spotlighting the best bagels in Nassau County, highlighting seven standout shops, each offering something unique to elevate your bagel experience.

Nestled in the heart of Great Neck, Bagel Hut is a neighborhood institution that has been serving fresh, hand-rolled bagels for decades. Known for their light, fluffy texture, and slightly crispy crust, these bagels are the perfect base for any topping. Customers rave about their old-school vibe and friendly service. Bagel Hut also offers an impressive array of cream cheese spreads, from classic scallion to indulgent bacon-flavored options.

Must-Try: Whole wheat everything bagel with veggie cream cheese.

If you’re looking for authentic, traditional bagels, Hand Rolled Bagels in New Hyde Park is the place to go. As the name suggests, every bagel here is meticulously hand-rolled, boiled, and baked to perfection. Their bagels are generously sized and have a satisfying chew. The shop also boasts a strong deli selection, making it a great choice for breakfast or lunch.

Must-Try: Onion bagel with lox and cream cheese.

My Three Sons Bagel Café combines the art of bagel-making with a full-service café experience. Located in Garden City, this shop offers a wide variety of bagel flavors and gourmet sandwich options. Known for its friendly service and cozy ambiance, this spot is perfect for a leisurely breakfast or a quick bite on the go. Their French toast bagel is a standout, offering a sweet twist on the classic bagel experience.

Must-Try: French toast bagel with maple walnut cream cheese.

A & S Bagels in Franklin Square has earned its reputation as one of the best bagel shops on Long Island. Open 24/7, this shop caters to bagel lovers at all hours. Known for their oversized bagels with a perfect golden crust, A & S keeps it simple with a focus on quality and freshness. Whether you’re craving a classic bagel or a fully loaded breakfast sandwich, they’ve got you covered.

Must-Try: Everything bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese.

Bagelicious in East Meadow lives up to its name, offering delicious bagels that are both fluffy and flavorful. This family-owned shop prides itself on using high-quality ingredients and traditional baking methods. Their extensive menu includes everything from sweet bagels like cinnamon raisin to savory options like asiago cheese. Bagelicious is also known for its wide variety of homemade cream cheese spreads.

Must-Try: Asiago cheese bagel with garlic and herb cream cheese.

Bagel Boss is a household name on Long Island, and their Hewlett location doesn’t disappoint. Known for its kosher-certified menu, Bagel Boss offers an impressive range of bagels, sandwiches, and pastries. The everything bagels here are a fan favorite, loaded with just the right amount of seasoning. They also cater to dietary preferences with gluten-free and vegan options.

Must-Try: Sesame bagel with lox spread and capers.

For bagel lovers in Oceanside, Bell’s Brooklyn Bagels & Bialys is a must-visit. This shop blends the flavors of Brooklyn with a Long Island twist. Their bagels are praised for their dense, chewy texture and authentic taste. In addition to bagels, they also serve perfectly baked bialys, a rare treat in the area. The shop’s warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a local favorite.

Must-Try: Garlic bagel with whitefish salad.

From classic flavors to innovative creations, the bagel shops in Nassau County, Long Island offer something for every palate. Each of these locations stands out for its dedication to quality and flavor, making them destinations for locals and visitors alike. The next time you’re craving a bagel, head to one of these standout spots for a true Long Island experience.

Have a favorite Nassau County bagel shop we missed? Share your pics with @VisitNassauCountyLI and be entered to win some Nassau County faves!